this post was submitted on 08 Aug 2025
663 points (99.4% liked)
/r/50501 Mirror
1214 readers
698 users here now
Mirrored /r/50501 Popular Posts
founded 5 months ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Maybe we're all too sensitive? Just spit balling here, maybe it's okay to criticize this aspect of Kristy Noam's behavior. It would not be okay to criticize someone who isn't a public figure like her for "this behavior" but she is a public figure and an extremist one.
Treating her the same as other people who get a lot of non-restorative plastic surgery isn't right because she isn't like them. She's a deeply racist public figure who's needlessly killed multiple animals who's also have obviously had a lot of cosmetic surgery. She doesn't represent everyone who's had plastic surgery.
No, her being extremist doesn't make it ok to be sexist towards her. Like you should be able to criticise Caitlyn Jenner without being transphobic. Or Milo Yiannopoulos without being homophobic.
But making fun of her getting such plastic surgery targets everyone who gets them. Just like making fun of someone for being fat targets every fat person, like calling someone gay as an insults is insulting towards every gay person. I'd argue her being a nazi makes it even less ok since of all the things you could be focusing on you're focusing on something that she fully in her right to do. It makes everything else you say easily dismissable and opens you up to accusation of sexism, because it is sexist to shame and try to humiliate a woman because of how she presents herself in public.
Just like how she is now brushing past all the other criticism south park has of her and focuses on the sexist aspect of her portrayal.
This has nothing to do with trans people. The reason someone gets plastic surgery is what people are free to judge. If you were her, would you get plastic surgery? If you say no that doesnt mean you are generalizing or stereotyping all people that have plastic surgery done.
I dont agree that south park was making fun of all people with plastic surgery either, watch the episode, its very exclusively and personally about Kristi Noem.