How is this any different from Overseerr?
this post was submitted on 20 Mar 2025
97 points (98.0% liked)
Selfhosted
44713 readers
1176 users here now
A place to share alternatives to popular online services that can be self-hosted without giving up privacy or locking you into a service you don't control.
Rules:
-
Be civil: we're here to support and learn from one another. Insults won't be tolerated. Flame wars are frowned upon.
-
No spam posting.
-
Posts have to be centered around self-hosting. There are other communities for discussing hardware or home computing. If it's not obvious why your post topic revolves around selfhosting, please include details to make it clear.
-
Don't duplicate the full text of your blog or github here. Just post the link for folks to click.
-
Submission headline should match the article title (don’t cherry-pick information from the title to fit your agenda).
-
No trolling.
Resources:
- selfh.st Newsletter and index of selfhosted software and apps
- awesome-selfhosted software
- awesome-sysadmin resources
- Self-Hosted Podcast from Jupiter Broadcasting
Any issues on the community? Report it using the report flag.
Questions? DM the mods!
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
Or Jellyseer for us jellyfin users.
Or my favorite, Jellyseer. Seems to have mostly the same features. But I'm always looking for more and better.
Ive just installed jellyseer last week and I love it!
I think the scope of this project is more ambitious with the additional media types as well as being a recommendation engine and an arr suite manager
I missed the Readarr part in my initial read through, but that is exciting. Jellyseer kind of has a recommendation section, mostly in popular and trending movies. I think it pulls from Trakt? Not entirely sure on that one. Either way, I'm looking forward to trying Mediawolf.
Here's the rundown from the repo:
Proposed Project Features:
Books (Readarr & Anna’s Archive)
✅ Missing List → Read from Readarr, fetch missing books and auto-download via Anna’s Archive ✅ Manual Search → Search Anna’s Archive and download books (user selection and defined file structure) ✅ Recommendations → Generate book suggestions based on Readarr library (using a background tasks to scrape from Goodreads) - with options to add or dismiss suggestions including filters and sorting
Movies (Radarr & TMDB)
✅ Recommendations → Read Radarr library and suggest similar movies via TMDB (with options to add or dismiss suggestions including filters and sorting) ✅ Manual Search → Search via TMDB with option to add to Radarr
TV Shows (Sonarr & TMDB)
✅ Recommendations → Read Sonarr library and suggest similar shows via TMDB (with options to add or dismiss suggestions including filters and sorting) ✅ Manual Search → Search via TMDB with option to add to Sonarr
Music (Lidarr, LastFM, yt-dlp, Spotify)
✅ Manual Search → Search Spotify for music and download via spotDL (which uses yt-dlp) ✅ Recommendations → Generate artist recommendations from LastFM based on Lidarr library (with options to add or dismiss suggestions including filters and sorting) ✅ Missing List → Read Lidarr library, fetch missing albums and download via yt-dlp
Downloads (via yt-dlp)
✅ Direct Download Page → Input YouTube or Spotify link and download video/audio using spotDL or yt-dlp
Subscriptions (via spotdl and yt-dlp)
✅ Schedule System → Subscribe to YouTube Channels, Spotify or YouTube Playlists and download on a schedule
Read the GitHub, for one Overseer/Jellyseer don't work for books or music. But there's more to this than just a request tool.
I just use this
Thats a cool project as well! I dont think there's very much overlap in functionality between the two
Right now, if you want to add a new movie or TV show, you probably:
Search for it manually across different Arr services
I mean, you only search one arr service depending on the media type.
Check which quality profiles or indexers work best for that media type
Figure out if it's already available somewhere in your library
You've already setup your quality profiles and indexers for your Arrs when you initially configured them, so there's no need to do that every time you add a new item. If it's already in your library, it shows when you search for it so not much figuring out.
Manually add it to the right service
Again, you've already searched in the appropriate Arr service for the media type. The "manual" action is pressing "Add", which i assume you'd need to do with this too?
I think I'm confused as to what problem this actually solves?
I mean, you only search one arr service depending on the media type.
I guess here I was more thinking about having audio books and ebooks with the same title across two separate instances of readarr.
If it's already in your library, it shows when you search for it so not much figuring out
Yeah that is true, not so much a benefit but does help that all media types are manageable from the same dashboard
The "manual" action is pressing "Add", which i assume you'd need to do with this too?
A reference to The benefit of having a recommendation engine auto add stuff for you. But I guess lots of the arr programs also have list imports but I'd prefer to not to depend on an external service for that sort of thing.
I think I'm confused as to what problem this actually solves?
I'm realizing now that in my excitement I have done a very poor job of describing the scope of this project, and would like to recommend that you visit the repo and check it out yourself:
https://github.com/MediaWolfOrg/MediaWolf
Here's is a snippet from the project pages that does a much better job of describing it than I did (apologies again for my poor description)
Proposed Project Features: Books (Readarr & Anna’s Archive)
✅ Missing List → Read from Readarr, fetch missing books and auto-download via Anna’s Archive ✅ Manual Search → Search Anna’s Archive and download books (user selection and defined file structure) ✅ Recommendations → Generate book suggestions based on Readarr library (using a background tasks to scrape from Goodreads) - with options to add or dismiss suggestions including filters and sorting Movies (Radarr & TMDB)
✅ Recommendations → Read Radarr library and suggest similar movies via TMDB (with options to add or dismiss suggestions including filters and sorting) ✅ Manual Search → Search via TMDB with option to add to Radarr TV Shows (Sonarr & TMDB)
✅ Recommendations → Read Sonarr library and suggest similar shows via TMDB (with options to add or dismiss suggestions including filters and sorting) ✅ Manual Search → Search via TMDB with option to add to Sonarr Music (Lidarr, LastFM, yt-dlp, Spotify)
✅ Manual Search → Search Spotify for music and download via spotDL (which uses yt-dlp) ✅ Recommendations → Generate artist recommendations from LastFM based on Lidarr library (with options to add or dismiss suggestions including filters and sorting) ✅ Missing List → Read Lidarr library, fetch missing albums and download via yt-dlp Downloads (via yt-dlp)
✅ Direct Download Page → Input YouTube or Spotify link and download video/audio using spotDL or yt-dlp Subscriptions (via spotdl and yt-dlp) ✅ Schedule System → Subscribe to YouTube Channels, Spotify or YouTube Playlists and download on a schedule
I'd say this seems useful mostly for pulling non nbz/torrent sources from readarr and lidarr services
Yeah I agree, it seems like a super nice hole to fill as sourcing music, ebooks and audio books from Usenet or torrents without being in a private tracker club is trickier than it should be