A new neighbor moved in and is really advocating for them, but I think most people in the HOA are split. It's come up after some recent thefts after someone left a garage door open. I'm thinking of organizing my arguments like this:
- Even with a camera capturing a thief's face, police are unlikely to actually catch the person or retreive the stolen property.
- Invasion of personal privacy, I don't like being tracked and my whereabouts being monitored
- Surrendering biometric data without my consent
- Police / ICE using the data without permission to harass our residents
How does this sound? It's so exhausting fighting against this. Does anyone have any other good points or articles that can provide support? Many thanks in advance
Cameras allow the HOA to monitor residents, whether or not they're technically allowed to
This is a good one, and perhaps, depending on your jurisdiction, it could open the HOA to potential civil litigation for privacy violations. There may also be requirements for reporting or retention if law enforcement or a court requests it, and that's additional overhead.
This is a great point. Do the cameras have microphones? Is it a two-party/all-party consent state?
Now you need to get consent from every person who might end up being recorded.