this post was submitted on 31 Jul 2025
703 points (97.7% liked)
pics
24048 readers
632 users here now
Rules:
1.. Please mark original photos with [OC] in the title if you're the photographer
2..Pictures containing a politician from any country or planet are prohibited, this is a community voted on rule.
3.. Image must be a photograph, no AI or digital art.
4.. No NSFW/Cosplay/Spam/Trolling images.
5.. Be civil. No racism or bigotry.
Photo of the Week Rule(s):
1.. On Fridays, the most upvoted original, marked [OC], photo posted between Friday and Thursday will be the next week's banner and featured photo.
2.. The weekly photos will be saved for an end of the year run off.
Instance-wide rules always apply. https://mastodon.world/about
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Source?
Most American Jews moved here before the end of WW2, after the diaspora we lived all over Europe and elsewhere for centuries. Nearly half of all Jews live in America, and have for generations now - since before the state of Israel was created
We didn't come here from Israel, we don't have "family back home". I really doubt most of us have ties to Israel at all
Couldn't find any exact study, I guess it would depend on how you measure it, but everyone in this post says it's very common.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Judaism/comments/17z5q4s/is_it_common_for_jews_in_diaspora_to_have/
And yeah, very few Jewish people in America are from Israel but lots of people from the US moved there from after WW2.
Yeah... That's just a small collection of anacdotal evidence, and my anacdotal evidence totally contradicts it
Look at the subreddit name. Why would you be in that subreddit? Probably because you're invested in the religion side of our culture, which is totally optional. Or you're into our history. These are things that make you more likely to visit Israel, a place full of historical, religious, and cultural artifacts
You seem more genuinely ignorant than anything darker, so let me take this opportunity to lay it out
Israel has a promise to all of us - we will protect our own next time someone does a genocide. Because the Holocaust wasn't the first time we experienced ethnic cleansing... Were the ones who look like the people where we live, but are different. I like to say, "we're always second", because when they run out of gypsies or black people, the fascists will need a next enemy
Israel offers free trips to young adults. You fly over, see the sights, and get indoctrination against Palestinians. I tried to do this years back before I knew the details... But there's another natural requirement. You have to be an active part of a group that focuses on Jewish heritage - I showed up a few times, applied, but I'm an American first and foremost. You need to be an active member of a Jewish identity group to even get in... And this is my heritage, not all I am. So I was filtered, like most of us are
The Palestine issue was uncomfortable for a long time...I mean, it's was definitely uncomfortable, but it was a guaranteed safe harbor. I think this is how most of us felt... Conflicted
But then October 7th happened, and the response made it clear what this was. We had to confront what this was, and most of us are very upset about it, because our history is being on the other side of it
And now, they're coming for the Latinos. I know how this story ends, and I don't want to be deported to Israel. I know it sounds crazy now, but it's not. We're 2 years away from "putting the Jews back where they belong"
We are not Israeli. Those people are fucking crazy, don't put me in the same breath as them. Don't apologize for the IDF. Don't launder what is happening.
Make the difference clear in your mind and in your words.
No one is reading that
False
Thanks
Fine - then just don't make excuses for Jews being tied to Israel. We're not, we're Americans and citizens of where we've lived for generations
That's an ignorant and prejudiced take, not to mention dangerous
Colonists